Asian Youth Gangs:
Close to Home
- By Theresa M. Ronquillo, Second Year Administration
One afternoon in 1994, two carloads of teenagers drove up
alongside another group of teenagers hanging out. From one of
the cars, a sixteen year old boy pulled out a Mac-12 semiautomatic
handgun and fired several times into the group. As a result,
another teenager tragically lost her life. The trigger-man was
convicted of first-degree murder for the drive-by shooting and
sentenced to fifty-two years in a state penitentiary. According
to some newspaper reports, he was a bright, talented student
who came from a stable middle-class family. However, unbeknownst
to his family, he was also a member of a loose-knit gang composed
of Filipino and Southeast Asian youths. The victim, a non-gang
member, got caught in the crossfire between two rival Asian youth
gangs.
The proliferation of youth gangs and violence nationwide unfortunately
renders a story such as this one all-too-familiar. It is now
common to read about such events in newspapers and watch them
on the evening news. Yet, while the distressing stories of these
gang youths may provoke feelings of grief and anger, many of
us choose to ignore the realities of gangs and gang violence
typically found in inner cities, ghettos, and barrios. However,
the incident recounted above continues to be profoundly real
and personal for my family and I as the trigger-man is a relative.
Nearly five years later, when I think about his tragic mistake
and its consequences, I am still filled with emotions of disbelief,
confusion, anger, and remorse for the victimÕs family
as well as my own. Similar to other families forced to deal with
such an immensely tragic event, my family has had an extremely
difficult time accepting that such an incident could actually
happen.
His case has compelled me to probe into the deeper issues surrounding
the Asian youth gang phenomenon. Because I knew relatively little
about Asian youth gangs, I had many pressing questions and set
out to find answers through my courses, fieldwork, and research.
This article attempts to examine the answers to several of the
most significant questions. These include: what causes Asian
youths to join gangs? What purposes do gangs serve in these youths'
lives? How are Asian gangs distinct from other ethnic and white
gangs? How do the police, agencies, and communities address the
Asian youth gang phenomenon, i at all? And, similar to youths
from lower-class backgrounds, why are many youths from middle-class
upbringings unable to escape or protect themselves from the debilitating
consequences of gangs and gang violence?
- Characteristics of Asian Youth Gangs
Since Asian youth gang members comprise a small proportion of
youth gang members reported by either law enforcement or non-law
enforcement organizations (1.6% and 2.2%, respectively) [Spergel,
1995], research regarding Asian youth gangs is somewhat limited.
Nonetheless, the emergence of Asian youth gangs in communities
with large Asian concentrations has attracted the attention of
law enforcement agencies, consequently generating some useful
information about []this particular phenomenon (Chen & True,
1994). According to Spergel (1995), growing numbers of criminal
and violent Asian youth gangs were reported in the 1970s, 1980s,
and early 1990s. These gangs have dispersed from the West and
East coasts to inland American cities. Spergel has identified
various factors that have contributed to the development of Asian
youth gangs. First, the expansion of immigration quotas during
the 1960Õs and 1970Õs perpetuated the influx of
Asian immigrants and refugees into the U.S. In some cases, immigrant
youths formed their own distinctive ethnic gangs or they became
integrated into older established gangs (Spergel, 1995). Second,
social isolation of new Asian immigrants and tension between
Asian immigrant groups and other ethnic and white communities
may also encourage the formation of Asian youth gangs 's defensive
groups to protect against the hostility of the established youth
groups and gangs'(Spergel, 1995, p.68).
Gang research reveals that a complexity of social, cultural,
and familial factors may lead to gang membership. Though there
may be some variations among the different Asian cultural groups,
a number of background factors have been identified as potential
causal factors for Asian gang affiliation: financial rewards,
status, peer pressure, and feelings of power and camaraderie
with other members. Family conflicts, the lack of supervision
at home, and the inability to succeed in school because of English-language
problems and cultural conflicts, as well as alienation from the
larger community due to racism have also been cited as significant
factors for gang affiliation (Chen & True, 1994). Asian gangs
have significant differences from typical African American, Latino,
and white gangs. For example, compared to other gangs, Asian
youth gang activities (with some exceptions) place less emphasis
on graffiti and the protection of 'turf'and territory. They also
tend to be more secretive than non-Asian gang members. Indeed,
'secrecy and remaining anonymous to law enforcement is a constantly
sought goalÓ (Operation Safe Streets Gang Detail, 1994,
p. 41). As their street presence is relatively low, it is subsequently
difficult for police to penetrate these gangs. Finally, Asian
youth gangs are also less interested in status, honor, or reputation;
they are more involved in criminal-gain and money-generating
activities such as extortion, burglary, and the sale of narcotics
(Spergel, 1995). In accordance, the increase in the number of
crimes and the degree of criminality perpetrated by Asian gangs
seems to be rising, particularly among Asian immigrant youth
(Chin, 1990). For instance, an investigation into violent deaths
in Los Angeles revealed that the percentage of gang-related homicides
for Asians was 4.8% of the total- a figure that was higher than
the percentages for Whites and African Americans (1% and 2%,
respectively) [Chen & True, 1994].
It is also important to recognize the numerous variations among
Chinese, Filipino, Indochinese (Vietnamese, Cambodian, Thai,
Laotian, and Hmong), and other Asian gangs. For instance, Japanese,
Taiwanese, and Hong Kong youth gangs are reported to be better
organized and more secretive (Spergel, 1995). Many Japanese and
Chinese gangs tend to resemble more organized crime syndicates
rather than street gangs. These gangs may invest in legitimate
U.S. business in order to accommodate their illegal activities
(e.g. money laundering, illegal gambling) and to present a facade
of legitimacy and respectability (Operation Safe Streets Gang
Detail, 1994). Chinese youth gangs are also often closely associated
with well-established adult groups and controlled to a considerable
degree by them (Spergel, 1995). On the other hand, Indochinese
gangs, Pacific Islander gangs, and Filipino gangs embody more
typical characteristics of street gangs. They are more involved
in auto theft, burglaries, and the theft and resale of weapons.
Furthermore, many of these gangs have adopted characteristics
of Black and Latino gangs, such as the styles of dress and speech;
certain Samoan gangs are even reported to have been assimilated
into Black gangs. Vietnamese gangs, unlike other ethnic gangs,
are often extremely mobile because they are not embedded in Vietnamese
communities. They may engage in regional or nationwide crime
sprees, committing robberies in different U.S. cities. Violent
acts are said to be relatively more likely among Vietnamese,
Chinese, Cambodian, and Laotian youth gangs, as compared to Khmer
or Hmong gangs (Spergel, 1995). Finally, it has also been observed
that some Asian gangs, Filipino gangs in particular, may evolve
from well-educated and affluent families (Operation Safe Streets
Gang Detail, 1994). This is a clear indication that the formation
of Asian youth gangs cuts across all socioeconomic lines and,
therefore, is not a phenomenon concentrated solely in economically
depressed communities.
The Lack of Chicago Data
It is important to emphasize that most information on Asian youth
gangs comes from large cities (e.g. Los Angeles) that have experienced
a marked emergence of Asian youth gangs and have chosen to further
investigate and gather data on the phenomenon. In contrast, information
from the Chicago Police Department and other criminal justice
authorities is virtually devoid of Asian youth gangs, perhaps
because they still consider the Asian youth gang problem and
its societal impact in Chicago to be low, as compared to Latino
and African American gangs.
Regardless of whether or not the phenomenon is significant or
large enough to be characterized as a 'problem,' it is unfortunate
that the city has consistently failed to acknowledge fully the
presence of Asian youth gangs. The minimal attempts to address
the emergence of Asian gangs in Chicago have been ill-equipped.
For example, until recently the FBI's Asian Gang Task Force was
comprised entirely of white officers. Yet, Asian police officers
would be more likely to make meaningful contacts with Asian gang
members and Asian community members than non-Asian officers.
Just as the Chicago criminal justice community places little
focus on Asian youth gangs, many Asian communities continue to
insulate themselves from them. And, many Asian communities believe
that while other ethnic groups have a gang problem, they themselves
do not. While most Asian youth gangs target members of their
own community in their criminal activities, the reporting of
Asian gang-motivated crimes is quite low because Asians generally
distrust law enforcement and/or may be fearful of gang retaliation.
In 1996, police estimated that at least 250 youths were involved
in Asian gangs in Chicago (Chicago Tribune, 1996). However, due
to the fact that three years have elapsed and crime reporting
is still low, the number and nature of Asian youth gangs in Chicago
remains uncertain. Such daunting barriers render it even more
imperative that attention and resources are devoted to the emerging
Asian youth gang phenomenon in order to increase needed awareness
in the pan-Asian community as well as the larger Chicago community.
In order to compensate for gaps in the research and data and
to better assess the pan-Asian community's knowledge of and exposure
to youth gangs in Chicago, I developed and administered a short
gang awareness survey to 60 Asian high-school students on the
North side of Chicago. Preliminary analysis of the data reveals
that exposure to and awareness of gangs in general is indeed
growing among this population. 82 percent of the respondents
reported that they have a general sense of what a gang is. An
item that asked respondents if they could identify the names
of gangs in their community produced 11 distinct gang names.
74 percent reported that they see gangs hanging out at school,
and 44 percent reported that they see gangs hanging out in the
neighborhood. Also, 45 percent reported some level of fear in
going to school because of gangs or gang activity occurring there,
and 35 percent reported some level of fear in going to certain
parts of their neighborhood. Although this survey was not comprehensive
and the pool of respondents was small, the preliminary results
clearly suggest that gangs are indeed a presence in this community
and in the students' daily lives.
- Implications for Policies and Programs: A Culturally Relevant
Approach
- In order to adequately accommodate the cultural variations
found among different Asian youth gangs, interventions addressing
the Asian youth gang phenomenon must be culturally relevant.
To gain a better understanding of gang structure, motivation,
and behavior, which are often related to ethnicity and culture,
programs targeting Asian gangs should encompass indicators of
cultural sensitivity, such as language capability, ethnic minority
staff members, cultural training, and the involvement of gang
members in the development of programs in order (Goldstein &
Soriano, 1994). It is important not to underscore however the
significance of three vital cultural sensitivity goals: (1) knowledge
and objectivity in espousing non-biased evaluative judgements
of behaviors exhibited by gang members and the cultural groups
they represent; (2) making useful contacts with gangs and communities
through culturally similar and/or linguistically-appropriate
staff; and (3) receiving input from gang members and the cultural
group they represent.
As Asian gang awareness in the pan-Asian community and the larger
community needs to be heightened, a community organizing approach
to this phenomenon would be both appropriate and effective. Community
organization or neighborhood mobilization efforts would attempt
to bring together various community members, groups and agencies
to push for coordinated efforts to address concerns related to
Asian gangs (Goldstein & Soriano, 1994). The ultimate goals
of such efforts are to enhance community empowerment and develop
and implement solutions through collaborative problem solving.
Community organizing initiatives that address the Asian youth
gang phenomenon should include the following:
¥ Establish trusting connections between the police and
the pan-Asian community in order to reduce fear in crime reporting.
Developing a more respectful, productive rapport may result in
positive outcomes, such as the participation of the community
in needed public safety activities and training community members
in gang recognition and intervention procedures.
¥ Increase awareness throughout the different communities
by holding community forums and educational workshops for Asian
parents and families. The forums and workshops would provide
a safe place to discuss issues such as the causes and potential
signs of gang affiliation, as well as imparting valuable intervention
methods to use with children such as effective parent involvement
and communication.
¥ Develop and implement Asian youth gang prevention and
intervention strategies such as educating young people about
the dangers of gangs, providing alternative youth activities
and job opportunities, and youth and family counseling.
¥ Mobilize support from community leaders, agencies, churches,
schools, etc. from the various Asian communities and coordinate
program activities through the different institutions.
-
- Conclusion
The Asian youth gang phenomenon is complex and distinct, yet
unfortunately understudied. Much of the available research on
Asian youth gangs is concentrated in certain urban areas; therefore,
it is possible that such information may not be representative
of the general Asian youth gang population. Although Chicago
has a substantially growing Asian immigrant population, and therefore,
an emerging Asian gang presence, communities and criminal justice
centers have continued to fail in appropriately addressing this
particular phenomenon. Due to this lack of attention, there are
very few Asian youth programs that tackle the gang component.
More attention, resources, and research can and should be directed
towards Asian youth gangs and the development of interventions
and programs nationwide. Whether or not my relative could have
benefited from such interventions is impossible to say. What
is certain is that the debilitating situation my relative finds
himself in now and for the rest of his life (as well as thousands
of other young people like him) should send a clear message to
all of us who are concerned about youth gangs. We must become
increasingly aware of the violent realities that penetrate the
lives
of youth, families, and communities, and start taking action
to address the entire youth gang problem, rather than
concentrate predominately on what is most visible, widely researched,
or well-published.
|
|